Pros and Cons of API vs Extract-based Integration of HR Systems to AD

When setting up a Hire2Retire workflow to automate employee lifecycle between HRIS systems and Active Directory (AD), you have the option of an API-based or an extract-based integration with HRIS to get employee lifecycle events. In this article, we will go over the pros and cons of each integration approach to help you make the right choice for your organization.

Extract-based Integration with Hire2Retire

With an extract-based integration, Hire2Retire will get data from the HRIS system as a file either pushed by HRIS or pulled by RoboMQ. The file-based extract is delivered to RoboMQ securely with RSA Key based authentication and encryption to ensure data integrity, privacy, and security. 

Pros and Cons

The setup process of extract-based integration is extremely straightforward and easy to implement. The data is extracted from the HR system and processed by Hire2Retire finally landing on AD or Azure AD as an identity profile. This integration promotes superior guaranteed delivery and data integrity as the SFTP based transfers are less error-prone and maintain guarantees of delivery at a bulk record level. This is further ensured by RoboMQ through its use of message-queue based transport. Also, you can control what you share with third parties like RoboMQ by strictly choosing what employee profile attributes are sent by HRIS.

However, since extract-based integrations operate on a batch processing model, the data is processed periodically or in a schedule-based way rather than in near real-time. Also, in this option, the one-time setup engagement with HRIS tends to consume time and may incur delays depending on the responsiveness of the vendor. 

API- based Integration with Hire2Retire

With an API-based integration, data transfer and communication happen over welldefined, published, and standardized application programming interfaces. A real-time connection is established between the HR system and RoboMQ to get employee lifecycle events which are processed to AD or Azure in AD in near realtime.

Pros and Cons

Since, the APIs are already published by the HRIS vendor, and the setup is as easy as authenticating an API key, almost no setup is needed in this option. With API-based integration, the data sync operation between HR and AD or Azure AD is swift resulting in near real-time updates to AD identity profile. Also, in API-based integration, you can write back to email or other AD data to HR, automatically sending some crucial information back to the HR system and further automating the Hire2Retire process.

On the other hand, this integration is dependent on APIs to be provided and published by the HR system vendor. Furthermore, data elements that are shared are determined by the HR vendor and the customer cannot choose what not to send. However, RoboMQ will process only the attributes that are required by the employee lifecycle and identity provisioning workflow for the customer and discard the rest reducing the impact of this con. 

We understand each organization has unique resources and objectives, and it may not be a simple decision to pick a data integration method that aligns with your needs and goals based on generalized facts. You can always Speak to an Integration Specialist at RoboMQ to compare these two integration methods and make an informed decision to kickstart your automation journey with Hire2Retire.

Want to learn more?

Picture of Somya Shrimal
Somya Shrimal

Somya Shrimal is an Associate Marketing Specialist at RoboMQ. She is a tech enthusiast and a prolific blogger who helps businesses stay up-to-date with the latest trends and best practices in the industry. Her expertise in SaaS, cloud, on-premises apps, and IoT has made her a go-to source for businesses looking to navigate the ever-changing tech landscape.

Picture of Somya Shrimal
Somya Shrimal

Somya Shrimal is an Associate Marketing Specialist at RoboMQ. She is a tech enthusiast and a prolific blogger who helps businesses stay up-to-date with the latest trends and best practices in the industry. Her expertise in SaaS, cloud, on-premises apps, and IoT has made her a go-to source for businesses looking to navigate the ever-changing tech landscape.

Dynamically Assign Security Groups or RBAC Based on HR Employee Profiles

Use Cases

Dynamically Assign Security Groups or RBAC Based on HR Employee Profiles


Posted onJuly 3, 2023
How To Dynamically Assign Security Groups or RBAC Based on HR Employee Profiles Use Cases Shalini Taknet July 3, 2023 Assigning security groups and role-based access control (RBAC) based on HR employee profiles can be a challenging task for organizations. Manual...
Share Workflows as Recipes

Use Cases

Share Workflows as Recipes


Posted onMay 5, 2023
How To Share Workflows as Recipes Use Cases Bramh Gupta May 5, 2023 Hire2Retire is used to automate employee lifecycle and identity provisioning, including access to third-party application systems. Essentially it integrates data from HR system to AD or Azure AD (or...
Impersonate Users to Manage Workflows Across the Organization

Use Cases

Impersonate Users to Manage Workflows Across the Organization


Posted onMay 4, 2023
How To Impersonate Users to Manage Workflows Across the Organization Use Cases Bramh Gupta May 4, 2023 It is typical of SaaS products that the functionality is associated with and owned by the licensed end user. Thus, the operations provided by the SaaS products are...